She was all mine on Christmas Eve last year
When he came along
He had this glimmer in his eye
My baby fell for him like
Stars fall from the sky

He swept her off her feet into the sky
And as they crossed the moon
I saw them laughing in his sleigh
His big white bag of toys just left me blues to play

It happened oh so quick
My baby fell for old St. Nick

Oh, maybe it's because he smokes a pipe
Like high society men do
Or perhaps I'm just not the jolly type
But baby I can learn to make kids smile too, hoh

I write the North Pole every day for her
But she don't seem to hear
The lonely cries of a lost reindeer
She only hears the sound of elves
And year 'round Christmas cheer

It happened oh so quick
My baby fell for old St. Nick

Oh, maybe it's because he smokes a pipe
Like high society men do
Or perhaps I'm just not the jolly type
But baby I can learn to make kids smile too, oh

She was all mine, on Christmas Eve last year
When he came along
He had this glimmer in his eye
My baby fell for Nick like stars fall from the sky

It happened oh so quick
My baby fell for old St. Nick
It happened oh so very, very quick
My baby fell for old St. Nick